Smooth caramel buttercream sandwiched between two chewy apple pie oatmeal and molasses based cookies
Worthington Weekly Special
Caramel Apple Oatmeal Cream Pie
(Available 10/5-10/11)
Smooth caramel buttercream sandwiched between two chewy apple pie oatmeal and molasses based cookies
Chocolate Chip
(Always Available)
Warm vanilla base with melty semi-sweet chocolate chips
Apple Pie
(Available 10/1-10/31)
Warm apple pie base with a hint of cinnamon and buttery graham cracker streusel, rolled in a crunchy layer of graham cracker streusel
Chai Latte
(Available 10/1-10/31)
Chai base topped with a fluffy vanilla bean buttercream, finished off with a light and aromatic cinnamon dusting. Served at room temp for optimal texture
Chocolate Peanut Butter
(Always Available)
Warm dutch cocoa base with creamy REESE'S® peanut butter chips
Cookies 'n Cream
(Always Available)
Warm vanilla base made with creamy white chocolate chips and crunchy OREO® Cookie Pieces
Pelotonia Pistachio Raspberry
(Available 10/1-10/31)
Warm raspberry base with crunchy pistachio bits, finished with a zig zag of white chocolate pistachio drizzle
*25 cents from every one of these cookies sold will be donated to Pelotonia.
Pumpkin Roll
(Available 10/1-10/31)
Warm pumpkin base with the perfect blend of sweet cinnamon and fragrant nutmeg mixed in, topped with a decadent cream cheese frosting
Rainbow Iced Sugar
(Always Available)
Warm sugar cookie base topped with a creamy rainbow vanilla frosting
Snickerdoodle
(Always Available)
Warm sugar cookie and sweet cinnamon base rolled in our subtly crunchy house cinnamon sugar blend
Fridays & Saturdays are for the… Brookie bombs!!
Basic B Brookie Bomb
(Available Every Friday & Saturday)
Warm chocolate chip cookie base layered with a double stuffed Oreo® cookie and another layer of fudgy chocolate brownie
Topped with crunchy M&M's®
Cowboy Brookie Bomb
(Available This Friday & Saturday)
A warm Cowboy Cookie base (Vanilla and Oatmeal base, with Dark Chocolate, Pecans, and Coconut), stuffed with a White Chocolate Coconut Crunch core, covered by a warm Dark Chocolate Brownie layer, topped with Caramel, Shredded Coconut, and Maldon Sea Salt
We got accolades…
#2 Cookies in the nation
USA Today Readers’ Choice 2025
Best Cookies in Columbus
Columbest 2026
Best Cookies in Columbus
Columbest 2025
Best Cookies in Columbus
Columbest 2024
Best Cookies in Columbus
Columbest 2023
Best Cookies in Columbus
Columbest 2022
EXCELLENT
Based on 1108 reviews
Posted on
Ash
Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
It is not an exaggeration to say these are the best cookies I’ve ever eaten. The chocolate chip is perfection.
Posted on
Sarah Fueger
Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Lions Cub is a celebratory staple in our house. The cookies are always so good! The flavors are always just right, and the classic chocolate chip is a go - to. We had the cookies at our wedding, they made perfect individual desserts. If you like a chunky cookie, you will love these.
Posted on
Lyndsey Lawwell
Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Hands down the busy christening chip cookies I have ever had! They always have fresh variety!! I will choose lions club over crumble any day!! 10 out of 10 recommend 👌
Posted on
Vanessa Rivera
Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Staff was so nice!
Posted on
Samantha Zirkle
Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Delicious cookie. Great service. So hard to decide on just a few to take home! Black raspberry chocolate chip is my new favorite 🍪