Creamy marshmallow fluff buttercream sandwiched between two chewy oatmeal and molasses based cookies
Worthington Weekly Special
Cubfetti
(Available 3/2-3/8)
Chilled vanilla birthday cake base with creamy white chocolate chips, golden cookies n' cream bits and Lion Cub's colored sprinkles finished with a vanilla bean buttercream and crunchy birthday cake streusel
Chocolate Chip
(Always Available)
Warm vanilla base with melty semi-sweet chocolate chips
Chocolate Peanut Butter
(Always Available)
Warm dutch cocoa base with creamy REESE'S® peanut butter chips
Cookie Butter
(Available 3/1-3/31)
Warm vanilla and Biscoff Cookie Butter base stuffed with Biscoff Cookie Butter and topped with even more Biscoff Cookie Butter
Cookies 'n Cream
(Always Available)
Warm vanilla base made with creamy white chocolate chips and crunchy OREO® Cookie Pieces
Lucky Lion
(Available 3/1-3/31)
Warm Lucky Charms® base with a hint of vanilla, filled with fluffy cereal marshmallow and topped off with a creamy Lucky Charms® frosting swirl
Monster
(Available 3/1-3/31)
Warm peanut butter oatmeal base with rich peanut butter chips, creamy chocolate chips, and crunchy M&Ms®
Rainbow Iced Sugar
(Always Available)
Warm sugar cookie base topped with a creamy rainbow vanilla frosting
Snickerdoodle
(Always Available)
Warm sugar cookie and sweet cinnamon base rolled in our subtly crunchy house cinnamon sugar blend
Thicc Mint
(Available 3/1-3/31)
Warm dutch cocoa base infused with mint and filled with decadent dark chocolate chips, gooey Andes Mint bits
We got accolades…
#2 Cookies in the nation
USA Today Readers’ Choice 2025
Best Cookies in Columbus
Columbest 2025
Best Cookies in Columbus
Columbest 2024
Best Cookies in Columbus
Columbest 2023
Best Cookies in Columbus
Columbest 2022
EXCELLENT
Based on 1009 reviews
Posted on
Samantha Simmerman
Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Best cookies ever!!
Posted on
Alexandra T
Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Amazing cookies! So much better than Crumbl cookies, too. I like the size of them and different flavors.
Posted on
Laura Belle
Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Ordered online at 7am for a 3pm pick up. Accidentally pressed 8am pick up. It was so early in the morning but I gave a call and I was so impressed someone answered. The team member was so kind and helpful. Always a great experience but so lovely to be able to talk to an actual person who is helpful and pleasant at 7 am. Love supporting this small business and their team!
Posted on
Leslie Torres
Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
These cookies are a family favorite! We love how soft they are!!
Posted on
Brett Younkin
Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Locally owned and made in-house. Great flavors and not afraid to push things a little.
It's worthy of the praise and national recognition they're getting.
Posted on
Savannah F
Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
These cookies are simply amazing. Best spot in town. My husband and daughter love the cosmic cookie, and I love the iced almond sugar cookie. They are the perfect size - not oversized but also just right to feel worth every bite.
Posted on
Kathy Raudabaugh
Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
This is the best cookie shop in Columbus by far. Every single cookie is perfect. Decadent. Incredible. Oh god, the diabetes is coming for me…uuuuuuuung